My recent post on autism has apparently sparked some interest (hello Trinity students!), which I’m not altogether surprised at: autism is a hot topic these days, and for good reason. It’s especially a matter of concern for teachers, who are now faced with a greater likelihood of having a student on the spectrum mainstreamed into one of their classes.
Well, besides all of the nice comments that the last article sparked (despite the fact that it was mostly about my own personal dealings with autism as the parent of an autistic child and not really about education in general), I happened to get a message through facebook from a former classmate of mine who student taught and graduated at the same time as I did back in the spring. This message, however, was not about teaching and ASD but instead about teaching with ASD.
In the message, my classmate mentioned that she had struggled with teaching somewhat during the course of the education program we were in and decided (very wisely) to seek out counseling if student teaching did not proceed well because she seemed to have the content and pedagogical competence as well as the motivation to succeed. When student teaching did not proceed well, she followed through, and within a few sessions, the counselor had suggested Asperger’s syndrome. I think, in a way, her experience is somewhat similar to my own except that her concern was more significant given that it was a detriment to her chosen profession of teaching: she wanted to find an answer for why things weren’t working, and according to her, hearing this even without an official diagnosis was a relief.
But when I discussed this issue with her, my thought was not about my own desires for an answer being vindicated. She recalled hearing one of our professors talk about a former candidate who was unable to pursue teaching because of Asperger’s, which made me think, How many potential teachers are out there that are unable to follow through on their desire to become educators simply because of the obstacles of having some form of ASD?
And then immediately after: And are there any teachers out there who do manage to teach with ASD? If so, what obstacles do/did they face, and how do/did they overcome them?
It’s a fascinating question to me, and I’m afraid that I can’t find anything on it after the brief amount of research that I’ve done. Still, I have a hard time believing that teachers like this don’t exist out there, and I think that maybe their experiences could benefit individuals like my former classmate who have the passion and desire to teach but don’t know how to adapt their own unique neurological wiring to the needs of their own students in the classroom.
If you are an active (or former) teacher living with some form of ASD or if you know an active or former teacher who is open about their ASD and would like to share their experiences, please contact me at docereestdiscere AT gmail DOTcom. I would love to hear about how teachers deal with this so that it can be used to help others who might be able to join us in this noble profession with the knowledge of strategies and techniques that will be effective and useful. And if you know of any research on this subject, contact me as well!
October 19, 2009 at 12:41 pm
Mr. B,
First let me thank you for your efforts at documenting your student teaching experiences – this has proven to be an excellent reference for my students and student teachers at Trinity. I’m also intrigued by your wonderings about teachers who have succeeded despite (or perhaps even because of) various special needs. Sounds like a doctoral dissertation, if you are so inclined, someday.
Another site that I have had my students exploring is that of Brad Cohen at http://www.frontoftheclassbook.com. Brad has Tourette syndrome and was rejected over 20 times from potential teaching jobs due to his tics. Brad went on to become a “teacher of the year” in a school that eventually took a chance on him.
In my Intro to Special Education class all of my students must do a research project on a disability. It’s surprising how often they come away from this experience wondering if, they too, might be accurately placed under certain labels such as Asperger, OCD. ADHD or learning disabled. My challenge as a teacher trainer is knowing when to suggest that teaching may not be the best fit for personal characteristics – but I always want the student to try to come to that decision because sometimes a true dsire to teach can overcome needs that are special.
Thanks again… and please keep blogging.
Prof Post
October 19, 2009 at 8:12 pm
I’m reading Teaching Hope right now (the teacher version of The Freedom Writers Diary) and one of the first stories in it is from a teacher with autism. It’s not super extensive, but it still might be interesting for your purposes. (I’m not sure if s/he has other stories in the book – I’m not very far as I can’t get through one before I start to tear up, and more than two or three before I’m actively crying. Which is awkward when I’m trying to read while in line at the bank, say, or waiting to see my dentist.)
January 28, 2010 at 8:45 pm
There’s a teacher in Brampton, Ontario, Canada with Asperger’s who teaches an ASD class. I read an article about her. However, the article was on the bulletin board at the Asperger’s Society of Ontario (where I get counseling–I have an AS diagnosis as well as ADHD, I don’t know if I ever told you that), so I’m not sure where to find it. I’ll try to remember to ask about it next time I’m there.
January 28, 2010 at 8:56 pm
Also: My experience trying to be a camp counselor with ASD ended up being spiritually abusive and deeply traumatic. I can email you with the long, awful details if you want.
January 29, 2010 at 10:26 am
I didn’t realize you had either, actually (or might have simply forgotten), although I knew you’d struggled with college and such for similar reasons. I might look into that and see if I could contact the society for information, provided I ever get the motivation (or time, ha) to pursue this further.
Thanks for stopping in, K.
January 29, 2010 at 7:46 pm
It’s possible that you left the board before I got my official diagnoses (June 2007). I know I never advertised the AS there even after that.
I really, really feel for the people who try to go into teaching, mysteriously can’t do it, and turn out to have AS. I didn’t have a diagnosis when I attempted camp counseling as a 16-year-old–just some suspicions, and no ASD-knowledgeable professional help. I’m attempting to go into the autism therapy field now, but my social skills are much better than they were then. I’m also being open about my diagnoses (which has gotten nothing but positive results, amazingly), working with small groups of kids alongside other people with more experience, and trying to be very self-aware in the process.
January 30, 2010 at 11:55 am
That sounds like a good route for you, given your experiences. I hope it works out for you in the long run.
(P.S. Thanks for reminding me about this topic. My interest is starting to revive in it, and I now have some better contacts that might give me a starting point to researching this topic further.)
January 31, 2010 at 3:45 pm
Thank you, and you’re welcome!
March 25, 2022 at 1:40 pm
This is a very insightful and informative comment. Thank you to the author for sharing this information.